|
ARCH comment on the Spring 2005 attendance figures for
England and Wales, released 21/09/05
Truancy: if you always do
what you’ve always done, you’ll always get what you always got
The latest truancy figures are back at
1994 levels, with an increase of more than 10% (see
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/4265536.stm) and the Government’s
reaction has shown exactly why things can only get worse. Instead of admitting
that radical ideas are needed, the Government is subjecting us to the same tired
old bluster and macho threats. Prosecute more parents, even more quickly? Well
that’s really going to help children value their education. Send parents to
prison and put their children in care? Just take a look at the truancy rates of
looked-after children.
It’s strange that a Government so wedded
to the management techniques of industry cannot recognise that the answer to a
seemingly intractable problem isn’t to carry on doing even more of the same. If
a Chief Executive behaved like that, shareholders would justifiably start asking
questions about his competence.
Truancy is getting worse, despite a
string of initiatives that have cost close to £1bn. Why? Until we try to
understand the reasons, there isn’t any point in quick-fix prescriptions. What
happens to turn a bright, curious toddler into a young person who is completely
turned off from learning?
Maybe we should start asking children
themselves for some ideas, because it’s pretty clear that adults haven’t got a
clue what to do.
Other reading -
NFER report on fast track
ARCH report on
Truancy Sweeps
|